Up, up and away! A place for comic-book fans to gather.

Friday, May 05, 2006

First thoughts: "Civil War" vs. "Crisis"


So there I was last night, with my stack of new comics, debating: What to read first? The first issue of Marvel’s much-trumpeted “Civil War” or the last issue of DC’s “Infinite Crisis” miniseries?

I went with “Civil War.” The story moves at a rapid pace, starting with a fight between the New Warriors, a superhero team starring on a reality TV show, and some villains. The battle ends on a horrendous note as a bad guy called Nitro blows up the neighborhood - killing hundreds of bystanders. That, in turn, revs up the debate over the Superhero Registration Act, an effort to regulate superheroes and hold them accountable. It’s compelling and it’s believable, though the quick turn from talk to action seems a bit rushed.

As for “Infinite Crisis,” I feel a bit let down. With the first few issues, I rushed to the comic-book shop, dying to know what would happen next. But in the end, I’m left wondering what it was all for.

There were some good scenes throughout the series, but also a lot that didn’t hang together or rang false. For example, the last issue opens with Superman, Batman and Wonder Woman looking down at the body of Superboy, killed the issue before, and blaming themselves, saying they should have been there. And then it ends with them saying, oh heck, let’s just take a year off and leave it to everyone else to defend the planet.

2 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

I guess because I have always been a dc fan for many many years. I love the old JLA JSA, earth-1 -infinity. This is what I want in comics, fun, some serious but nothing that is a reflection of the world we live in. Civil War is almost too real to the point of disturbing. We live in a world of hate, racism, nationalism, and all surrounded by politics. That is the last thing I want to see in a comic. There were no humor in Civil War, the coloring was very dark and dismal. I felt I was watching CNN (yes, nice promo logo in the book). Crisis was action, a little sad of losing Earth-2 Superman but colors were bright, we all knew in the end the coming year will be filled with fun. All I can see with Civil War is sadness, and mirror realty no one wins or wants, no fun, lost hope. What dreadful reading for a sunny summer day. However, I will continue to buy and read it just to satisfy my curiosity. My 2-cents, nothing more.

6:01 PM

 
Anonymous bill radford said...

I agree, if you're looking for some fun escapism, "Civil War" isn't the way to go. I don't mind "Crisis" not being about something real, I just wish it had hung together better. For example, Donna Troy was supposed to have a key role, then seems to be forgotten. How was she a key player?

3:24 PM

 

Post a Comment

<< Home